Rules for main forums
- Be nice
- No advertisement
- No events
- No fundraisers
- No topics asking for votes
- Only posts related to Judo
Question for BB-peers at Judochecker: which Rank to claim?
1 month(s) ago • 179 views • 2 replies
4th DanVerified
1 month(s) ago
Hi folks,
I did not claim a Yon-Dan from 2007 so far. Reason is, it was without a test and awarded for serving 15 years as a BB and achievements in Judo during that time (Coach of the official Judoteam of the University of the German Armed Forces, long-standing service as a military close-combat instructor and over and beyond volunteer coaching of young athletes and kids).
Promoted and signed by Andre Le Capitaine (5th Dan Kodokan) under IMAF (International Martial Arts Federation) Europe, the certificate is posted on my profile.
On one hand it is not important to me to hold a higher rank and after claiming I will loose my verification and all of my given points will disappear, too. :-(
On the other hand there will be a lot more verification points in the system after a 4th degree is (re)verificated. :-)
What I want to know against this background is:
Should I claim a Yon-Dan at Judochecker?
So please be so kind as and give Your honest opinion. ;-)
I did not claim a Yon-Dan from 2007 so far. Reason is, it was without a test and awarded for serving 15 years as a BB and achievements in Judo during that time (Coach of the official Judoteam of the University of the German Armed Forces, long-standing service as a military close-combat instructor and over and beyond volunteer coaching of young athletes and kids).
Promoted and signed by Andre Le Capitaine (5th Dan Kodokan) under IMAF (International Martial Arts Federation) Europe, the certificate is posted on my profile.
On one hand it is not important to me to hold a higher rank and after claiming I will loose my verification and all of my given points will disappear, too. :-(
On the other hand there will be a lot more verification points in the system after a 4th degree is (re)verificated. :-)
What I want to know against this background is:
Should I claim a Yon-Dan at Judochecker?
So please be so kind as and give Your honest opinion. ;-)
Edited 3 week(s) ago
4th DanVerified
1 month(s) ago
As someone who is still only ranked 4 dan after being promoted to 3 dan over 30 years ago (and remained active and teaching ever since), I can definitely sympathize. I, for one, would have no problem voting for you at 4 dan.
3rd DanVerified
1 month(s) ago
I would vote for you. You have a legitimate certificate for yondan. I don’t think it matters that there wasn’t a test, since promotion after sandan is mostly based on teaching and promoting the art, which you have done. You would just need to explain why you skipped ranks, but I don’t think that would be a problem. The only downside is that since JudoChecker has only recently come back online, it might take a week or two for you to get enough votes to be verified again.



