RegisterLog in
Main forum

PGF Pro Judo

5 day(s) ago • 70 views • 4 replies

Sebastian Ellinghaus
Sebastian Ellinghaus
4th DanVerified32 forum posts1200/1000
4 day(s) ago
The ruleset is a nightmare for old style guys like me.
It consequently follows the way of Judos destruction:
No newaza at all and it is designed as a show of spectacular throws. 😔
If I want something like that, I can watch WWE. 💁🏻‍♂️
Zack
Zack
2nd DanVerified7 forum posts1075/1000
3 day(s) ago
As to everything, there are pros and cons.

Pros: significant increase to penalties such as stalling.
Fast paced.
Match cannot be decided by a quick 3-5 sec rush for a takedown.
Promotes being in shape in general as opposed to strictly judo shape.
Draws in a new crowd to judo.

Cons: definitely takes away from what judo is at its core, and makes it more of a show and tell of nage-Waze as opposed to a wholistic art.
No ground work.
Could potentially put someone with simply better cardio over those who are actually better at judo.

Obviously there is a lot more to it than that. Someone on a different forum post the other day talked about how judo isn’t super popular in the states compared to Europe/Asia etc. I think one amazing take away (avoiding being cynical) is that this rule set will likely appeal to the American populous a lot more. It might be useful as a bridge to generate more interest for the sport as a whole.

I honestly didn’t hate it. But I agree calling it judo definitely gives the wrong idea and would be better off getting called something gimicky like “Judo Roulette”.
Edited 3 day(s) ago

Post a reply

Add a quote
 
Changes saved
Success
An error occured
Required fields missing
This person is already on Judochecker.